It’s crucial to note: genuine faith manifests differently in individuals. These red flags aren’t about judging someone’s heart, but identifying potentially harmful behaviors that may coexist with a veneer of piety. Remember, abusers and manipulators exist in ALL walks of life, including religious ones. Protecting yourself spiritually and emotionally requires a bit of discernment.
1. She Uses Scripture as a Weapon for Judgment, Not Grace.
Cherry-picking Bible verses to condemn everyone else while glossing over those about forgiveness and mercy is a major sign of spiritual immaturity. Genuine faith understands we ALL fall short and focuses on self-reflection. If she constantly fixates on other people’s so-called “sins” rather than her own growth, that’s a red flag.
2. “Praying for You” Is Said with a Smirk.
This passive-aggressive put-down masquerades as concern. It’s about making herself feel superior, not genuine well-wishing. Healthy Christians lift others in prayer; they don’t make a performance of it to signal their own piety, The Gospel Coalition points out. Be mindful of condescension disguised as a spiritual act.
3. Gossip Is Justified as “Prayer Requests.”
Spreading other people’s personal business under the guise of seeking prayer support is harmful, no matter how it’s packaged. Authentic faith respects privacy and creates an environment where people feel safe to share struggles without fear of their business being broadcast throughout the congregation.
4. She Rigidly Focuses on Externals (Modesty Policing, etc.).
Obsessing over the length of skirts or how many earrings you wear distracts from true spiritual growth. While some churches have dress codes, the kind of “modesty policing” that shames women is about control, not faith. Jesus looked past externals to the heart of individuals; be wary of those who do the opposite.
5. She Claims to Have All the Answers.
Faith involves grappling with complex questions! Someone who claims to have it all figured out, with simplistic answers for messy situations, lacks the humility true spirituality nourishes. A healthy relationship with God includes doubts, wrestling with hard truths, and a willingness to learn and evolve, not dogmatic certainty that discourages critical thinking.
6. She’s Only Nice to Those She Deems “Worthy.”
Putting on a show of kindness for pastors or those higher in social status within the church, but being rude to those perceived as less important, is the opposite of Christ’s teachings. True faith isn’t about performance, but sees the worth in ALL people, regardless of their position or apparent “usefulness”.
7. “This is Just How I Am, God Accepts Me!” (Without Trying to Grow)
Yes, God loves us in our imperfect state, but faith calls us to STRIVE toward bettering ourselves. Using spirituality as an excuse for hurtful behavior or refusing to acknowledge flaws shows stagnation, not healthy acceptance. We can be loved unconditionally AND be expected to work on treating other people with that same love.
8. She’s Unwilling to Consider Other Viewpoints, Even Respectfully Held Ones.
Rigidity and demonizing those with differing theologies is divisive, not what Jesus modeled. Faith communities can have healthy disagreements while respecting differing opinions. If she shuts down dialogue, declaring hers the ONLY correct one, it creates a climate of fear and stifles open spiritual exploration.
9. She Has Double Standards Based on Gender Roles.
Rigid expectations about “biblical womanhood”, while not holding men to the same standards, reveals a warped view of scripture. Faith can include choosing a traditional path, but when it becomes about enforcing control rather than personal choice, it’s problematic. Healthy faith communities value the unique ways ALL individuals reflect God’s image, not imposing limiting boxes on anyone.
10. She’s Intensely Focused on Finding a Husband, Making Marriage an Idol.
Wanting a partner is natural, but a frantic obsession with it as the ONLY path to fulfillment is unhealthy. Faith should offer meaning beyond marital status. A woman with a rich spiritual life values herself outside the context of romance. If marriage is seen as the solution to all life’s problems, it sets her up for co-dependent relationships.
11. “Submitting” is Her Favorite Topic, But Only for Other Women.
Scriptural concepts of submission get twisted when applied solely to wives, not as mutual respect within marriage. The Bible is full of verses about submitting to ONE ANOTHER. Someone harping only on women obeying is manipulating scripture for control. Healthy relationships have balance and a teamwork dynamic.
12. She Disguises Emotional Intensity as Being “Led by the Spirit.”
Dramatic displays of emotion can be part of worship, BUT when volatile emotions are chronically excused as being “filled with the spirit”, it becomes untouchable. This stifles accountability. True spiritual maturity includes emotional regulation and the ability to discern genuine spiritual experiences from outbursts used to deflect criticism.
13. She Claims She Has A Direct Hotline to God Himself.
While some people do feel a profound connection through prayer, claiming to get specific instructions from God about everyone else’s lives is a power play. Faith encourages us to seek wisdom through community and scripture, per Crossway, not rely exclusively on one person’s supposed divine downloads. Be wary of those who use this tactic to shut down differing opinions.
14. She Preaches Material Prosperity as Proof of God’s Favor.
God wants us to thrive, but equating financial wealth with righteousness is warped theology. It leads to either guilt for those struggling (not godly enough?), OR smugness for the wealthy (proof of their superiority). This encourages toxic comparison and ignores Jesus’ emphasis on caring for the poor, values the Bible clearly teaches.
15. She Has An Unhealthy Enmeshment with Her Parents, Especially Her Father.
Honoring parents is Biblical, but when she can’t make decisions without running to Daddy’s approval, that’s stunting. True adulthood involves individuating from family while maintaining close bonds. In romantic contexts, this sets up a dynamic where she’ll always prioritize her father over her partner, making for a rocky marriage.
16. She Love-Bombs Newcomers to the Church.
Overly effusive friendliness initially feels flattering, but if it comes with pressure to join groups/donate immediately, or if that love evaporates the moment you disagree with her on anything, that’s manipulation. Healthy churches welcome you warmly but allow space to settle in at your own pace.
17. She Views Suffering as Punishment for Sin.
Bad things happen to good people! This simplistic, hurtful view lacks the nuance true faith offers about a complex world where even the righteous endure hardships. Blaming those already hurting is the opposite of Christ-like compassion. It also creates fear, making people too scared to confide struggles in her as they’ll just be judged.
18. She Holds Conspiracy Theories Woven into a Spiritual Narrative.
Some Christians sadly fall down rabbit holes, seeing everything from vaccines to current events as demonic plots. While healthy faith includes discerning good/evil, this creates paranoia. It also makes rational discussion impossible, as she’ll dismiss opposing views as you being on the side of Satan. This leads to isolation, not true community.
Enjoy this piece? Give it a like and follow PsychLove on MSN for more!
